Affiliate disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Every fall, millions of people reach for scented candles, plug-in air fresheners, and synthetic room sprays to get that cozy autumn scent. The problem? Most of them are loaded with synthetic fragrance, phthalates, and VOCs that fill your home with the very chemicals you're trying to avoid.
A stovetop simmer pot is the clean alternative — and it smells better than any candle you've ever burned. Cinnamon, cloves, star anise, orange peel, and vanilla simmering low and slow on your stovetop will fill every room in your home with the most incredible, natural fall fragrance. No synthetic ingredients. No toxic byproducts. Just your kitchen doing what it does best.
Here's exactly how to make one — plus the non-toxic tools that make it easy, safe, and cleanup-free.
🍂 What Is a Stovetop Simmer Pot?
A simmer pot (also called a stovetop potpourri) is simply a small pot of water with aromatic ingredients — spices, citrus, herbs, and botanicals — simmered on low heat on your stovetop. As the water heats, it releases the natural fragrance of the ingredients into the air, acting as a completely non-toxic, chemical-free home fragrance.
Unlike candles or plug-ins, a simmer pot releases no synthetic fragrance compounds, no phthalates, no paraffin byproducts — just steam carrying the natural scent of real ingredients.
🌿 The Classic Fall Simmer Pot Recipe
Fill your saucepan with 4–6 cups of water and add:
- 2 cinnamon sticks
- 1 tablespoon whole cloves
- 3–4 star anise
- 1 orange, sliced into rounds (or just the peel)
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
- Optional: a few sprigs of fresh rosemary or a bay leaf
Bring to a gentle boil, then reduce to the lowest simmer. Add water as needed (every 30–60 minutes) to keep the pot from running dry. Your home will smell incredible within minutes.
Pro tip: Use the OXO Tea Strainer Basket to contain the cloves and star anise — it makes cleanup effortless and keeps small particles out of your pot.
🫙 Make a Dry Simmer Mix to Gift or Store
Combine the dry ingredients (cinnamon sticks, cloves, star anise, dried orange peel) in a glass jar and store for up to 6 months. When you're ready to simmer, just add the jar contents to your pot with water and vanilla.
This also makes a beautiful, thoughtful fall hostess gift — fill a Weck Tulip Jar, tie with twine, and add a handwritten tag with the recipe. Zero plastic, completely non-toxic, and far more personal than a store-bought candle.
🍳 The Clean Tools You Need
The pot you use matters. Conventional non-stick pans can release toxic fumes when heated — even at low simmer temperatures over extended periods. Here's what to use instead:
The Pot: Choose Stainless Steel or Enameled Cast Iron
18/10 stainless steel · No PFAS, no coatings · Oven safe to 550°F
Shop Now
Enameled cast iron · No PFAS, no seasoning needed · Superior heat retention
Shop Now
The Strainer: Keep Botanicals Contained
Extra-fine mesh · Cool-touch silicone handles · Dual-function lid · 4.8 ⭐
Shop Now
The Stirrer: Non-Toxic Options for Every Pot
BPA-free silicone · Heat-resistant · Safe for enameled cast iron · 3,200+ reviews
Shop Now
Non-toxic teak wood · BPA-free · Non-stick safe · Complete set
Shop Now
For Topping Off Water
Borosilicate glass · BPA-free · Microwave & dishwasher safe · 7,400+ reviews
Shop Now
For Storing & Gifting Your Dry Simmer Mix
All-glass · BPA-free · Airtight · Dishwasher safe · Beautiful enough to gift
Shop Now
💡 Simmer Pot Tips & Safety
- Never leave unattended — check every 30–60 minutes and add water as needed
- Keep it on the lowest setting — a gentle simmer is all you need; boiling wastes water and burns the botanicals faster
- Reuse your ingredients — the same batch can simmer for 2–3 days; store in the fridge overnight in your pot and reheat the next morning
- Don't drink it — simmer pot water is not tea; the concentration of essential oils from long simmering is not safe to consume
- Use filtered water if possible — it keeps your pot cleaner and extends the life of your botanicals
♻️ What to Do With Leftover Simmer Pot Ingredients
Don't toss everything when your simmer is done — most of what's in the pot has a second life.
The Citrus Peels
- Garbage disposal deodorizer — drop orange peels and a cinnamon stick down the disposal and run with cold water for an instant, natural refresh
- Fridge deodorizer — let the peels air dry completely, then place in a small open dish in the back of your fridge to absorb odors
- Compost — everything in a simmer pot is 100% compostable; add it all to your bin
The Simmered Water
- Natural linen or room spray — let it cool completely, strain out all solids, and pour into a glass spray bottle. Use within 2–3 days (refrigerate between uses) as a light linen spray or countertop freshener
- Drain deodorizer — pour it slowly down the kitchen drain to naturally freshen pipes
The Dried Botanicals
- Potpourri — spread the spent cinnamon sticks, star anise, and dried orange peel on a small dish to air dry completely, then place in a bathroom, closet, or drawer as natural potpourri
- Fire starter — dried cinnamon sticks and orange peel are excellent natural kindling for a fireplace or fire pit; they smell incredible as they burn
Nothing goes to waste. That's the beauty of a simmer pot made with real ingredients. 🌿
⭐ The Bottom Line
A non-toxic fall simmer pot is one of the easiest, most satisfying clean living swaps you can make. It costs almost nothing, smells better than any synthetic candle, and fills your home with warmth and fragrance the way nature intended. All you need is a clean pot, a handful of spices, and a little water.
Browse our full Clean Cookware collection for more non-toxic kitchen picks.
📖 Also Worth Reading
- The Complete Guide to Non-Toxic Cookware: 18 Clean Kitchen Picks for 2026
- 17 Non-Toxic Food Storage Products to Replace Every Piece of Plastic in Your Kitchen
- Are Air Fresheners Toxic? What to Look For (And What to Avoid)
Affiliate disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.